Beth's inconsistencies

[Chocoholic]

Beth's "interpretations" of the truth:

#1

VAN SUSTEREN: After looking at the video, what was the next sort of step in the investigation?
HOLLOWAY: Well, as far as what my concerns were, I wanted to find where this young man lived.
VAN SUSTEREN: Did you find that out?
HOLLOWAY: Yes, I did.
VAN SUSTEREN: How did you do that?
HOLLOWAY: That was just through a series of events that I really don't want to get into now...
VAN SUSTEREN: Did you ever talk to him?
HOLLOWAY: I never had a conversation with him.
No, I did not.
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,159779,00.html

#2

TWITTY: I think that the moment we arrived on the island and when we were in contact with these individuals, from May 31, from 1:00 AM to 4:00 AM, I knew immediately. I knew immediately.
VAN SUSTEREN: Have you personal contact with them?
TWITTY: Oh, yes.
VAN SUSTEREN: What did they say to you?
TWITTY: Well, it was very limited, but when the Van der Sloot young man approached the vehicle that I was seated in, he had the most condescending, arrogant, somewhat powerful attitude of any 17-year-old male I have ever seen.
VAN SUSTEREN: What did he say?
TWITTY: When he approached the car, I was holding a picture of Natalee. And I said, I want my daughter. I want her now. And he just threw his head back and hit his chest, and he said, What do you want me to do? What do you want me to do?
VAN SUSTEREN: Beth, thank you.
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,160231,00.html

#3
She claims that "immediately" she "knew" that Natalee had been kidnapped.

However, the first posters said "Hootie please call me, we need to talk."

#4

Lied about # of lawyers Joran has.

#5

And Natalee Holloway had absolutely no idea that she was getting into a car, anything other than an Aruban cab driven by an Aruban cab driver.
http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIP.../03/ng.01.html

The only way Beth would know this is if Natalee told her.

#6

Claims she has signed confession that prove that Joran admitted to sexually assaulting Natalee.

#7

Greta has indicated that she believes the gardener was less than credible, but she lets Beth spin the story anyway.


The credibility of the gardener:

BETH HOLLOWAY TWITTY: As far as this gardener coming forward, I`m really encouraged, Nancy. I mean, I think that`s a huge step forward for us. And you know, maybe it`s taken him a little while to have some assurance and trust in order to come forward and make sure there are no repercussions for him coming forth with this information.

http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIP.../15/ng.01.html

#8

Calling the Kalpoes criminals

"She called our client, Mr. Satish Kalpoe, a 'criminal,' 'involved in a violent crime against my daughter' and who is 'allowed to walk freely among the tourists and citizens,'

http://www.cnn.com/2005/LAW/07/06/aruba.missing/

[Chocoholic]

The Call Chapter 2 from “Loving Natalee”

The next call I make is to the U.S. Embassy in Washington, D.C. <snip> So I call back and talk to a vice-consul.
Apparently beth doesn't know that there is no such thing as a US Embassy in Washington or anywhere on US soil. Can somebody please inform her that she dialed the wrong number or that she is lying? Who can honestly buy this load?

From Chapter 3 from “Loving Natalee”


All the calls made to the FBI and the U.S. Embassy by Natalee’s brother and our friends must have paid off.
Again this is a lie. There is no US Embassy on US soil nor on Aruba for that matter.

More from chapter 3

Apparently, finding the local police was hard for him.

So let me get this clear. The DEA agent stationed on Aruba who knew before beth's arrival that Natalee had been kidnapped, was unable to open up a phone book to find the number to the police. Not only that when they arrived at the hotel where beth sanctified Natalee's purple bag, they were unable to ask the attendant at the front desk for the number to the police? Normally panic goes hand in hand with adrenaline and makes a person think very clearly. beth and the DEA agent seem to be utterly befuddled and incompetent.

From Chapter 5 from “Loving Natalee”

The media gathered because they thought they'd get a shot of Natalee being led out of a crack house. Disheveled. Dirty. Probably incapacitated. I can only imagine the shape she'd be in after four days in this situation. This was the image they wanted to show the world.

'You f-ckers! Get out of here! Get out of here!' I scream. How dare you try to tarnish her! There's no way I will allow them to see her like this. And photograph her.

LMAO after she just previously went into incredible detail about Natalee's shaven pubic area and her underwear this is supposedly tarnishing her image? What would make her think that Natalee would be incapacitated, dirty and disheveled in the first place? Did she know that Natalee was using drugs? I know of no habitual drug user who shares drugs with no strings attached.

The headline on the posters is changed to KIDNAPPED, because I believe after so much time has passed that this is indeed what has happened.
Interesting.

So the poster headings were changed because of what beth thought, not because of any evidence. Some even choose to believe it.

It must be at least ninety degrees at this predawn hour, but I put on one of Jug's jackets anyway to hide the four-day-old body odor.

Now that's yummy. Greta and Nancy have dared to say that Paul v.d.. Sloot must be guilty of something because he sweats in what beth calls a place so it is comparable to hell but she doesn't take the time to at least wash? BO wouldn't start to cover it, putrid might.

Chapter 7

It's the police spokesman calling the top line. "We have a girl, and we think she is Natalee. Go to Bubali station. We want you to identify her."

About this time Jug, who is out on searches, get the same tip from the island newspaper reporter. "Julia found a girl and thinks it's Natalee. Let's meet at Bubali."

The three women and I run to a cab. "Take us to Bubali station. Please! Hurry!"

OMG after all this time, all it took is tell a cabbie to “Take us to Bubali station” and you get to the police. If only they had thought of that on day 1.

[Chocoholic]

Beth's comped rooms:

August 11
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/8925176/

J. TWITTY
But the whole thing is—is frustrating to me. Last night, I saw something on TV. It was very frustrating, when Ruben Trappenberg said something to the effect that—somebody asked him about, well, you need to pay for all of the family‘s expenses. Oh, we are. You know, everything is comped, all the cab rides, all the hotels, all the—everything.

And, you know, that‘s so frustrating to me, Joe, it‘s unbelievable. I mean, I cannot believe the man came on there and said that, because...

SCARBOROUGH: So, is he lying?

TWITTY: ... I can‘t tell you how—absolutely. They are not paying for all our things. And, yes, they have offered to help us with a couple of things, but they are not comping our rooms down there. I put Beth in a nice hotel because I wanted security in there, and the owner of the hotel was nice enough to come and give us a discount on the room, but they are not comping our rooms.

They‘re not comping—I have there in probably 70 cab rides. I have never had anybody offer me to give me a free cab ride. It‘s just unbelievable to even come and say that. And I have seen my credit card bills, if they want to pay for it. I don‘t want them to pay for it. I don‘t want the Aruban government to give me a penny. All I want to do is, I want to find Natalee and I want to go home.

If she stayed free at the HI for six weeks...that puts the time frame in mid-July when she made the move to the Wyndham where Jug says 'the hotel was nice enough to come and give us a discount on the room.'

Beth left Aruba around Sept 5.

According to the book, she paid a final hotel bill of $19,000. for about 7 weeks, with a discount.

Hotel Contributions

http://www.aruba.com/holloway/index.htm

The Wyndham Resort (Lodging and work space for the family) Cost US $30,000.00
The Brickel Bay Hotel (Lodging, food and beverages of Equusearch) Cost US $100,000.00
The Holiday Inn (Lodging and meeting facilities) Cost US $ 89,736.00
Playa Linda Beach Resort (Lodging) Cost US $ 9,016.63

OOPSIES

Why would a mother of a missing daughter lie? Why oh why?

[Luke Davis]

Nice to see this in one place and organized.:hat:

[ortiga]

Thanks for organizing this! Just want to remind all that there is also an old thread too, on this board, that details many of Beth's earlier public statements, many of them inconsistent, or lies.

http://boards.crimelibrary.com/showthread.php?t=266178

[ortiga]

Beth's comped rooms:

August 11
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/8925176/

J. TWITTY
But the whole thing is—is frustrating to me. Last night, I saw something on TV. It was very frustrating, when Ruben Trappenberg said something to the effect that—somebody asked him about, well, you need to pay for all of the family‘s expenses. Oh, we are. You know, everything is comped, all the cab rides, all the hotels, all the—everything.

And, you know, that‘s so frustrating to me, Joe, it‘s unbelievable. I mean, I cannot believe the man came on there and said that, because...

SCARBOROUGH: So, is he lying?

TWITTY: ... I can‘t tell you how—absolutely. They are not paying for all our things. And, yes, they have offered to help us with a couple of things, but they are not comping our rooms down there. I put Beth in a nice hotel because I wanted security in there, and the owner of the hotel was nice enough to come and give us a discount on the room, but they are not comping our rooms.

They‘re not comping—I have there in probably 70 cab rides. I have never had anybody offer me to give me a free cab ride. It‘s just unbelievable to even come and say that. And I have seen my credit card bills, if they want to pay for it. I don‘t want them to pay for it. I don‘t want the Aruban government to give me a penny. All I want to do is, I want to find Natalee and I want to go home.

If she stayed free at the HI for six weeks...that puts the time frame in mid-July when she made the move to the Wyndham where Jug says 'the hotel was nice enough to come and give us a discount on the room.'

Beth left Aruba around Sept 5.

According to the book, she paid a final hotel bill of $19,000. for about 7 weeks, with a discount.

Hotel Contributions

http://www.aruba.com/holloway/index.htm

The Wyndham Resort (Lodging and work space for the family) Cost US $30,000.00
The Brickel Bay Hotel (Lodging, food and beverages of Equusearch) Cost US $100,000.00
The Holiday Inn (Lodging and meeting facilities) Cost US $ 89,736.00
Playa Linda Beach Resort (Lodging) Cost US $ 9,016.63

OOPSIES

Why would a mother of a missing daughter lie? Why oh why?

From the book: "The Holiday Inn has very generously provided our family a block of rooms free of charge for the six weeks we have been here. We are very, very grateful for their hospitable gesture beyond the call of duty. But it's time to move. The Wyndham Hotel gives us a reduced room rate on a very nice suite. Having a kitchenette will be very helpful, economically speaking as well as for convenience, as we hunker down for the duration of Natalee's case."

Quotes for readability, not necessarily referring to exact words spoken.

[Chocoholic]

I'm surprised she posted it and I don't know of another good place to post this:

Did Beth Sneak Natalee out of Aruba on a Plane? What Do You Think? Read This Email…
by Greta Van Susteren

Check out this comment I just received here on www.GretaWire.com…it is not an unusual one…I have received other ones with essentially the same content.

Greta,

The reason the police won’t help the “family”. Is because they know now that the “family” are the ones that orchestrated Natalee’s disappearance from the private airport on one of McWayne’s private aircraft. They have witnesses.

Just think Greta, soon you will be able to interview Beth from jail. Won’t that be a ratings getter!

http://gretawire.foxnews.com/2007/10/04/did-beth-sneak-natalee-out-of-aruba-on-a-plane/all-comments/