Whats Your Theory?

[ooJSMoo]

Whats your theory about what happened to Natalee Holloway?

[Luke Davis]

Natalee Holloway went to Aruba and is missing.

It seems likely to me that she died accidentally.

[Luke Davis]

Natalee enjoys the beach for awhile after Joran leaves. She then boards The Freewinds and cruises away.

Once a week (http://www.arubabycruise.com/news/TCKH.htm)

[Luke Davis]

Presidential candidate supports boycott (http://blog.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=blog.view&friendID=125578411&blogID=306666542)

Natalee meets some guys and goes for a boat ride with them to South America.

[Luke Davis]

Natalee is dropped off at a crack house. She dies. She is buried in the pet cemetery.

[No Nic]

Natalee leaves CnC with Joran,(believing she is getting a ride to the HI with another teen who is vacationing and also staying at the HI, as Joran told her). She is taken "somewhere" else by JK2. Unlike the 20 times before "something bad" happens causing Natalee's death. JK2 know they are responsible (inadvertently being the cause of the "something bad" that happened) and with the help of the elder VDS disposed of her body where it will never be found (most likely in the sea). Bottom line: NO BODY, NO CASE.

Are you proud, Paulus? Will your conscience ever get the best of you? Will we be hearing the name Van der Sloot in a similar case sometime in the future? My prediction is.............YES!! Joran is not finished !!

imo

[pnavas]

Natalee is alive, well, and on the move to avoid being found. She called her mother during those first hours to tell her that she needed to get away for a while. Unfortunately, she called too late -- her own private choice became an enormous media event. She's horrified, embarassed, and more than a little scared. Natalee knows full well that her return will cause a media explosion, and although it was an innocent and completely understandable choice, she may have some 'splainin to do. And so will her mother and the friends who helped her.

It's an awful lot for a young woman to face, but she'll return as soon as she feels ready.

That's my theory and I'm sticking with it.

JMO

[Chocoholic]

Who gave you the right to steal my words? lol

I agree, completely. But that's hardly a secret on this board. :D

[Luke Davis]

Natalee is walking down the beach when she comes upon some of the brookies. They are stripping off their clothes for a late swim. She joins them. Natalee is a great swimmer and is racing with her cousins when the current takes her far out. She calls for help, her cousins barely hear her but can't find her. She drowns and drifts off.

Her cousins are scared and gather her clothes and dispose of them. Later they will call home with stories of Joran hanging around all week, playing poker, grabbing Natalee, kidnapping her...

[Chocoholic]

Luke, you forgot the important part. The Twitty twins clammed up and had their lawyers answer their questions for them. They also didn't partake in the FBI/ALE questioning when ALE came to MB.

*insert Twitlight zone theme music*

[julianella]

I believe Natalee died accidentally. I believe this happened while she was in the company of the local boys. I beliieve they got scared and got rid of the body. I also believe PVDS is in the know of what happened. All CE points to Auba locals. The constant lies the still unanswered questions, IMO they know what happened to her. I don't think she ran and left everything behind, especially sine sh told one of the suspects that she was planning her future..ie College and so forth!

imo

[Mishell1383]

Natalee is alive, well, and on the move to avoid being found. She called her mother during those first hours to tell her that she needed to get away for a while. Unfortunately, she called too late -- her own private choice became an enormous media event. She's horrified, embarassed, and more than a little scared. Natalee knows full well that her return will cause a media explosion, and although it was an innocent and completely understandable choice, she may have some 'splainin to do. And so will her mother and the friends who helped her.

It's an awful lot for a young woman to face, but she'll return as soon as she feels ready.

That's my theory and I'm sticking with it.

JMO
I'm not attacking your post by any means, I am really interested. What makes you believe she called her mother to tell her she needed to get away?

[Mishell1383]

ps. Why didn't anyone tell me this thread was here!?:(
I thought you all loved me! LOL

[No Nic]

ps. Why didn't anyone tell me this thread was here!?:(
I thought you all loved me! LOL

:seeya: We do love ya, Mishell, but we didn't know where you were hiding. :)

[Devotion]

Luke, you forgot the important part.

The Twitty twins clammed up and had their lawyers answer their questions for them.
They also didn't partake in the FBI/ALE questioning when ALE came to MB.

*insert Twitlight zone theme music*

:( At the beginning, I thought it very strange, when the "twins" did NOT stay/ or fly back to Aruba and look for their cousin....
I find this entire case from beginning to end "strange"....JMO

[Chocoholic]

:( At the beginning, I thought it very strange, when the "twins" did NOT stay/ or fly back to Aruba and look for their cousin....
I find this entire case from beginning to end "strange"....JMO
This case is strange.

The mother of a woman who has disappeared claims that she "knew" from the moment that her daughter was late for her plane, she was kidnapped, brutally gangraped and murdered.

The same mother told the world that she had in her words "signed confessions". She doesn't. She doesn't have any confessions but they seem to make her feel better.

We've been told that there would be news which would be HUGE which was contained in the skeeter tapes subsequently altered and manipulated to change the content of the meaning of said tape. When it was made public that the tapes had not just been altered for time but for content she backed away as though it were a poisonous snake.

The mother of the woman who disappeared has stated that her daughter is sexuallly as naive as a 14 year old. Guess she hasn't been with too many 14 year olds lately. She also stated that her daughter didn't drink/drank responsibly but we know that Natalee was drunk pretty much around the clock.

Natalee, according to her mother didn't DO drugs, she was just in possession of them.

<*R>

Natalee's mother slandered 3 people as being known criminals when in fact they aren't criminals and have never been charged with any crime.

Natalee's mother is determined not to have any other suspects investigated, unfortunately for her she isn't in charge of the investigation and I'm certain that bothers her.

All in the light that no crime has even proven to have taken place. Not a single shred of evidence that has come to light, other than the falsification of a video tape by Paramount Studios aka doctored phil and bht slandering (in the eyes of the law) innocent people.

Very strange indeed.

I see no reason why a reasonable adult such as Natalee would not have run away, in light of jug's self admitted coachings and his apparent intimate knowledge of her. I see no reason why, in light of Nat's statements that she believed that her mother was Hitler's sister's daughter and that she didn't wish to return to Alabama, that she had any wish or reason to return to her stepfather's house, other than bht's supposed "truth".

All imo of course.

[Luke Davis]

Greta's opinion and many theories (http://gretawire.foxnews.com/2007/09/13/natalee-holloway-news-kalpoe-brothers-must-turn-over-documents/)

http://gretawire.files.wordpress.com/2007/09/aruba2.jpg

[No Nic]

From Luke's link:

And this third picture is taken from our hotel but is of the parking lot where Joran told us he and Natalee were dropped off by the Kalpoe brothers. You can also see the beach (left side of picture) where Joran told us he and Natalee then went. Note that I write “he told us” — it is impossible to know what really happened and where it happened…. I can only report what others told us:

Notice the bolded part. Does not sound like someone who is "inclined to believe" Joran, IMO.

[kjb19500]

It's probably been discussed 100x elsewhere, but I've always wondered what's the significance of NH signing off on HS yearbooks with the line from Lyndard Skynard's Freebird: "If I leave here tomorrow..."

I've always felt that she got on a boat (either voluntarily or involuntarily) for So. America and is either living there incognito or died there sometime later, depending on who her "companions" were.

[Chocoholic]

It's probably been discussed 100x elsewhere, but I've always wondered what's the significance of NH signing off on HS yearbooks with the line from Lyndard Skynard's Freebird: "If I leave here tomorrow..."

I've always felt that she got on a boat (either voluntarily or involuntarily) for So. America and is either living there incognito or died there sometime later, depending on who her "companions" were.

Even in a slow boat it would take no more than an hour to get to Venezuela. Nat, according to all who knew her so well, spoke Spanish fluently. There was nothing to stop her.

[Heyes]

I agree with the FBI, ALE and the Dutch investigators.
Kidnapping, rape and murder.
Thanks to paulus vandersloot, there is "no body, no case"!
Thanks to paulus's buddies, 10 days to get rid of evidence and a shot of railroading a couple of innocent security guards.
Well done aruba!

[pearyb]

Natalee Holloway went to Aruba and is missing.

It seems likely to me that she died accidentally.

I've felt that accidental death is possible simply because of how much of a role alcohol played in this trip.

[zurichsl]

okey i think what happened is they went to the bar and than - one - than she left them the guy`s went home and maybe she met some even here from the us than he followed even the had a relation ship here in the states . than she went down to have som fun than he followed boum was a set up for her or a set up for both .

- two - the guys left with her every buddy has drinked but the one guy by it self took her home in to hes house and / but that`s intresting it happened only if she really liked him who were arrested for it .
so he brought her home they might had sex andm ore drink than maybe foto or video happened and after that the way how she was maybe got it back some accident happened hmmmm ... may be not fatal but a little they`ve got scrared what to do big charges and all that maybe one of them finished the accident went out to murder case .... and they hide it some how somewhere like ocean

- three - well they didn`t tell any details but what i know that`s all i can think of ... but something strange in the story in either way sounds like a set up to me but somehow sounds too difficulted ... than a regular homocide or murder case !

i could look at her to might enjoy older people company i said that because she is looks actualy my type even i like older women too if i could that they could give a safe feeling .
just like my mother who has a secret boyfriend who dosn`t want to get know about him and old in hes sixty`s . but what`s strange that my mother wanted to learn engles and that she met a german male over the internet now so it is nothing simuler than uhm type of the case so after i`ve send her an email that i need to know about who you lieing about because i don`t think that is neccesery to hide anyone like behinde in the late 60`s ... plus the lies like i`m doing good wantedd to learn engles and than german bussiness man met her than now went out to a hungaryan bussinessman who dosn`t want to know about any anyone and want`s to hide like that not answering to phone calls getting far away from the other`s my mother is a perfect borned victim the serial killers can`t find easyer victim who they can blame fro their any kind of failaure in there life she is just perfect for it like nataly was .

[cactus4rx]

Whats your theory about what happened to Natalee Holloway?
I know this sounds crazy but I believe it to be true. Natalee woke up at sunrise. She was picked up by an older white male. He is missing a front tooth. He drives a 2 toned green and white 1950's car. I think he gave a tip to the police. Since there was only 2 tips given; you would think this would be easy. He lives in a dark brown house. He is a peculiar man that everyone pretty much avoids.
I also believe "John" from Haunting Evidence received a clue about me. "Cactus"
He saw the 1st half of her stay and I saw from when she woke up.

This guy has her chained up. Please someone.... Help. I don't know what to do. Honestly, I saw this sooooo clear. Just like I was standing on the beach watching it happen. She was carrying a blanket.

[One2Snoop]

I know this sounds crazy but I believe it to be true. Natalee woke up at sunrise. She was picked up by an older white male. He is missing a front tooth. He drives a 2 toned green and white 1950's car. I think he gave a tip to the police. Since there was only 2 tips given; you would think this would be easy. He lives in a dark brown house. He is a peculiar man that everyone pretty much avoids.
I also believe "John" from Haunting Evidence received a clue about me. "Cactus"
He saw the 1st half of her stay and I saw from when she woke up.

This guy has her chained up. Please someone.... Help. I don't know what to do. Honestly, I saw this sooooo clear. Just like I was standing on the beach watching it happen. She was carrying a blanket.

Have you notified authorities or Beth for that matter of your vision? :shrug:

[sieg66]

I think Joran drugged her with GHB or something like that in order to have sex with her. But since she had to much to drink she had a seizure and died. I think this was the reason that he did not call for help when she got sick and died. I think his father helped him to get rid of her. If I did something really stupid, I would call upon my family, not my friends. I mean they can always screw you over , no? I think Joran knows this now too. They just got lucky that she was never found....

[Ice]

I think she died on the beach of a drug overdose. I think the Vandersloot kid and his friends got scared and got some help disposing of her body.